Amoud Diallo New York 1991 Police Misconduct

In that case of Amoud Diallo four New York police fired 41 rounds into an African American.   The four police officers were tried  but acquitted.  In the civil lawsuit that followed the city settled for 3.5 million dollars.  Even though the officers were found to have shot under the reasonable belief that their life was in danger the civil  lawsuit claiming negligence was successful.   

 
 
 

 

Nick C. Thompson JD

800 Stone Creek Parkway Suite 6

Louisville, Kentucky

40223

(502)429-0057

 

Amoud Diallo New York 1991 Police Misconduct

 

Download our Self Defense and how to Carry Concealed Manual.   Visit our Law website Bankruptcy-Divorce.com for manuals on Bankruptcy Divorce Lemon Auto and other legal topics. Remember bookmark or link to our websites.    

The case of Amoud Diallo

Just after midnight February 4, 1999, four New York City cops took 41 shots at a street peddler named Amoud Diallo and the press then accused the shooting as racial.   The four undercover police officers from the Street Crime Unit cruised down Wheeler Avenue in an unmarked car.  The Street Crime unit aggressively sought out illegal guns.  Since their inception homicides had dropped 75%, they made 45,000 frisks in two years and 9,500 arrests, 2,500 were for illegal guns. One illegal gun arrest for every 18 stops making the work dangerous. 

The unit was looking for an armed rapist responsible for up to 51 assaults. They spotted Diallo who matched the description pacing nervously and peering into the windows of an apartment building.  Officers Carroll and McMellon identified themselves and asked Diallo to stop and raise his hands however he attempted to run and get inside the building.  In turning away Diallo reached into his pocket and pulled out a what seemed to be a gun although he only carried a wallet and a pager.   Carrol shouted "Gun, He's got a gun".  McMellon who followed Diallo up the stairs feared being shot point blank and fired three shots falling back down the stairs with such force that he broke his tailbone.  The other officers thinking McMellon was shot unloaded their weapons.  Their 9mm solid bullets failed to bring Diallo down prone and the officers continued firing 41 times. 

Although this was a tragic accident there was nothing to indicate that shooting Amoud Diallo was racial yet the officers were vilified by the press and the department settled for 3.5 million.  Similar cases have happened in Louisville Kentucky where totally naked persons or persons in handcuffs have been shot in justifiable homicide incidents which would be even more difficult for police to explain as to how they were going for a weapon.  The Prosecutor Eric Warner opened with "We will prove that by the number of shots fired at very close range, that this man -- who was cornered and killed in the vestibule of his home -- that these four defendants intended to kill him, and therefore are guilty of murder,"  The criminal trial took exactly 30 days to acquit and closed the crime unit which had saved so many lives. 

Every situation is different this is for information only and this is not legal advice.